Close Menu

Can My Spouse Delay A Bonus Until After The Divorce Is Final?

Can My Spouse Delay A Bonus Until After The Divorce Is Final

If your spouse is expecting a large year-end bonus, they might try to delay receiving it until after your Schaumburg divorce is final. If you think this could be happening, remember that the payment date alone does not always decide whether you have a claim to the money. I consider why the bonus is being paid, when the work was done, whether your spouse already has a right to receive it, and how much control your spouse has over the timing. Illinois courts look at whether the compensation has actually been earned or if it is a future bonus that is still up to the employer. This difference can decide whether significant amounts of money are included in the marital estate.

Illinois Law Presumes Property Acquired During The Marriage Is Marital

Under 750 ILCS 5/503, property acquired by either spouse after the marriage and before entry of the judgment dissolving the marriage is generally presumed to be marital property unless a statutory exception applies. The statute directs Illinois courts to classify property as marital or non-marital and distribute marital property in “just proportions” after considering the circumstances of the marriage and the parties.

So, I do not just look at whose name is on a paycheck or bonus statement. If the compensation comes from work done during the marriage, it might still be considered marital property, even if the money is paid out later.

Illinois courts have addressed this issue specifically in cases involving bonuses and deferred compensation. In “In re Marriage of Peters,” 326 Ill. App. 3d 364 (2001), the appellate court concluded that the portion of a contractual stock bonus earned during the marriage could constitute marital property even though receipt of the bonus remained contingent. The important consideration was that the employee had a contractual right he was working toward during the marriage.

The Difference Between An Earned Bonus And A Discretionary Bonus

Not every expected bonus is marital property. Illinois courts distinguish an enforceable compensation right from a mere expectation that an employer might award additional compensation.

In In re Marriage of Wendt, 2013 IL App (1st) 123261, the Illinois Appellate Court considered a bonus that could be paid after the divorce. The employee had no employment agreement guaranteeing the bonus, and the employer retained discretion over whether to award it. The court concluded that the potential bonus was an expectancy rather than an existing property right.

A similar principle was applied where an employer retained complete discretion over a potential bonus and the employee had no contractual entitlement to it before dissolution. The appellate court determined that such a bonus did not become property until it was actually paid.

This difference is very important. If your spouse has already met the requirements to earn a bonus and the payment is just being delayed, I may be able to argue that some or all of the bonus should be included in the marital estate. But if the employer can decide whether to pay the bonus at all, the situation could be very different.

Delaying The Payment Does Not Necessarily Change When Compensation Was Earned

Suppose your spouse normally receives a $75,000 bonus every February based on performance during the preceding calendar year. Your divorce is scheduled to be finalized in January, and your spouse asks the employer to move the February payment to March.

I would want to investigate that arrangement carefully.

Illinois decisions recognize that deferred compensation can constitute marital property when the underlying right was earned during the marriage. The Illinois Supreme Court has described deferred compensation as including forms of compensation such as bonuses earned for work already performed, and Illinois courts have distinguished those rights from compensation that remains speculative or entirely discretionary. Changing the date on which money enters a bank account does not necessarily erase the circumstances under which the right to the money arose.

Employment Records Can Reveal What Actually Happened

When a bonus appears to have been delayed, I may seek documents that establish the compensation history and the employer’s bonus practices. These can include employment agreements, bonus plans, payroll records, prior-year W-2 forms, performance reviews, compensation committee documents, emails concerning the bonus, and communications regarding payment dates.

Historical patterns can be particularly important. If your spouse received bonuses every year at roughly the same time and the payment suddenly changes during the divorce, that circumstance deserves examination. I would also determine whether the employer made the timing decision independently or whether your spouse requested a postponement. The objective is to determine whether the bonus represents an existing compensation right, a contingent contractual benefit, or merely the possibility of future compensation.

A Bonus Can Also Affect Maintenance

Even when a disputed bonus is not classified as marital property, it may still have consequences for maintenance. Under 750 ILCS 5/504, Illinois courts considering maintenance examine factors including the parties’ income and property, their needs, their present and future earning capacities, and other sources of income. The statute also establishes guidelines for maintenance in qualifying cases based on the parties’ incomes.

Therefore, a recurring bonus history may be financially relevant even when a particular future discretionary bonus cannot be divided as marital property. A spouse should not assume that postponing compensation automatically makes that compensation irrelevant to the broader financial issues in the divorce.

Bonuses May Affect Illinois Child Support

If the spouses have children, bonus compensation can also affect child support. 750 ILCS 5/505 broadly defines gross income for child-support purposes as income from all sources, subject to specific statutory exclusions. Illinois uses the parents’ incomes when calculating their respective shares of the child-support obligation.

For someone whose compensation includes substantial annual bonuses, commissions, incentives, or other variable income, I examine more than the person’s ordinary salary. A compensation structure that produces significant additional annual income can materially affect the financial picture used in a support case. Illinois law also permits courts to consider potential income in certain situations involving voluntary unemployment or underemployment.

Do Not Assume The Divorce Date Makes The Bonus Disappear

If you find out your spouse is expecting a big bonus soon after the divorce is final, do not assume you have no right to it. Whether you have a claim depends on the compensation plan, how much control the employer has, any contract rights, when the bonus was earned, and why the payment is happening after the divorce.

The difference between an earned bonus and a possible future payment can decide the result. That is why it is important to look into bonus compensation before you sign a marital settlement agreement or before the court gives a final judgment.

Illinois Divorce Frequently Asked Questions

Is A Bonus Paid After Divorce Automatically My Spouse’s Separate Property?

No. The date the bonus is paid matters, but it is not the only thing to consider. I would check if your spouse had a right to the bonus during the marriage and if the bonus was for work done during the marriage. Illinois courts treat bonuses that are guaranteed by contract differently from those that are up to the employer. If a bonus was earned during the marriage, it might be marital property even if it is paid later. But a bonus that is only possible and not guaranteed until after the divorce may be treated differently.

What If My Spouse Asked The Employer To Hold The Bonus Until After The Divorce?

I would look into that through financial discovery. I might ask for emails with the employer, bonus plan documents, payroll records, compensation records, and proof of past bonuses. If the bonus was already earned and only the payment date changed, delaying it does not always decide if it is marital property. Other evidence can show if there was a right to the bonus before the divorce was final.

What If The Employer Has Complete Discretion Over Whether A Bonus Is Paid?

That can make a big difference. Illinois courts have said that if the employer has full control over whether to pay a bonus and the employee has no contract right to it, the bonus is just a possibility, not a right. In that case, a bonus paid after the marriage ends may be non-marital property. Each compensation plan is different, so it is important to look at the details.

Can I Request My Spouse’s Bonus Records During Discovery?

Generally, compensation records can be highly relevant in a divorce involving property division, maintenance, or child support. I may seek employment contracts, compensation plans, payroll records, tax documents, prior bonuses, incentive agreements, deferred-compensation documents, and communications concerning anticipated payments. These records can establish whether bonuses are discretionary, contractual, recurring, performance-based, or attributable to work already completed.

Speak With The Law Office Of Fedor Kozlov About Bonus Compensation During An Illinois Divorce

If you think your spouse is trying to delay a bonus, commission, incentive payment, or other compensation until after your divorce is final, it’s important to look at the timing before you agree to a property settlement. I can review your compensation details, employment records, past payments, financial disclosures, and other documents to see how the payment might be handled under Illinois law. Taking care of this before the final judgment can help protect your finances and make sure no important compensation is missed.

The Law Office of Fedor Kozlov represents clients in Schaumburg and throughout Chicago, Illinois, in divorce and family-law matters involving property division, compensation, maintenance, child support, and other financial disputes. Contact our Schaumburg divorce lawyer at the Law Office of Fedor Kozlov by calling (847) 241-1299 to receive a consultation.

author avatar
Law Office of Fedor Kozlov, P.C.